The Right to Choose

Last week I watched my son do something that millions of people do without giving it a second thought. He voted.
When we arrived at the kalpi, our local polling station, Asaf was so excited, making all his happy noises.
He knew exactly why we were there, and he couldn't have been happier.
Before we even arrived, he had already made his political choice. With the support of his facilitator, he typed his choice who he wanted to vote for.
And then came the practical part. Have you ever noticed just how many little pieces of paper there are in an Israeli polling booth?

I couldn't believe how many political parties there were!
For Asaf, finding the correct ballot paper, picking it up, and physically placing his vote in the box wasn't straightforward. He needed our support, and we gave it to him.
But the choice was his. We weren't deciding for him. We were simply helping him carry out the decision he had already made.
Watching Asaf exercise his right to vote filled me with pride. But it also got me thinking.
How much choice does Asaf actually have in his everyday life?
And not just Asaf. How much choice do people with special needs really have?
How often do we, as parents, caregivers, teachers and professionals, make decisions for them without even stopping to ask what they want?
Sometimes it's the little things, such as what they're going to eat; what they're going to wear; what they're going to do that day.
And sometimes it's larger things: like where they're going to live; who they're going to spend time with and what kind of life they want for themselves.
We sometimes make these decisions for them because we love them and we want to protect them, because we believe we know what's best for them.
And sometimes, simply because it's easier.
I know how easy it is to decide for them because I do it myself.
I remember when Asaf was living in the hostel, and was desperate to leave. He typed the words:
I must have freedom of choice, like every other person, like everyone else.
Those words have never left me.
Because he wasn't just asking to leave the hostel. He was telling me something much bigger. He wanted a say in his own life. He wanted the freedom to choose.
And I realised that, as much as I loved him and wanted to protect him, I was sometimes making the very decisions he was asking to make for himself.
And I won't pretend that it's easy.
As a mother, I've spent so many years looking after Asaf, thinking ahead, anticipating his needs, protecting him, and making decisions for him. It's very difficult to change that way of thinking.
But I keep coming back to the same question.
When we decide that someone can't do something, have we actually given them the opportunity to try?
Have we given them the support they need?
And, perhaps just as importantly, have we given them enough time?
Yesterday evening, I asked Asaf what he wanted for dinner. He chose corn on the cob and onion bake.
Simple enough, right?
I made what he had asked for, put the food in front of him, and then he sat there for twenty minutes before he actually started eating.
Twenty minutes!
I don't know exactly what was going in Asaf’s mind during those twenty minutes. But I do know that he had made his choice, and eventually, in his own time, he began eating.
And it made me think about how impatient we can be.
We live in a world where everything needs to happen quickly. We ask a question, and expect an immediate answer. We offer a choice, and expect someone to act on it instantaneously.
But what if someone needs more time?
What if they need twenty minutes instead of two?
Does that make their choice any less valid?
I think sometimes we are so focused on getting things done that we forget to give people the time they need to do them.
And I wonder how many opportunities we take away simply because we don't have the patience to wait.
I talk a lot about presuming competence, and I really believe in it. But believing in it, and putting it into practice every single day, are two very different things.
It's easy to say that we should presume competence. It's much harder when we're tired, when we're in a hurry, when something feels risky, or when we think we already know what the answer is going to be.
There are times when Asaf needs a great deal of support, and that isn't going to change. But needing support shouldn't mean losing the right to make decisions.
Sometimes he needs someone to help him physically carry out what he has chosen. Sometimes he needs help communicating his choice. Sometimes he simply needs more time.
And sometimes I need to remind myself to stop, step back and let him try.
Of course, not every decision will be the right one. But how many wrong decisions have I made in my own life? How many things have I learnt because I was allowed to try, make mistakes and try again?
Why should Asaf be denied those same opportunities?
I don't have all the answers. I'm still learning, and I still catch myself making decisions for him when perhaps I should be asking him instead.
When I think back to the polling station, what stays with me isn't just the sight of Asaf casting his vote. It's the fact that he had made his decision long before we walked in. Our job was simply to help him make it happen.
And it makes me wonder how many other decisions are waiting to be heard, if only we ask, give enough time, and provide the support needed.
I know I won't always get it right. There will be days when I rush him, when I answer for him or make a decision out of habit. But I want to catch myself more often. To stop and ask him what he wants, and then give him the chance to show me, even when it takes longer or looks different from what I expected.
Years ago, sitting in his hostel, Asaf asked for freedom of choice, just like everyone else.
Last week at the polling station, he got to exercise that freedom.
But the real challenge for me is making sure that freedom doesn't end when we walk out of the polling station. That it carries into our kitchen, our plans, our ordinary days.
Because Asaf wasn't asking me to stop helping him.
He was asking me to stop choosing for him.




❤️